Vzvojna togost nekaterih avtomobilov

Tehnična vprašanja, ki se dotikajo različnih modelov

Moderator: Tehnika moderatorji

Odgovori
Pepsi
Addicted to Alfa
Addicted to Alfa
Prispevkov: 5161
Pridružen: Ne Jan 14, 2007 4:32 pm
Član Alfa Kluba: 0

zdravc napisal/-a:pa še to, bravo brava imata enako karoserijo kot 145 s popolnoma enakim podvozjem, na prvi strani si napisal kaksno vzvojno togost naj bi imela brava/bravo, torej 10800, 156: 11000.
potem si pa napisal da ima 145 okoli 7 oz. 8k. napisal si tudi, da bi morali govoriti predvsem o dejstvih, torej drzi se tega.

tvoja raziskava je zate.
ne vidim kako so tvoji viri glede vzvojne togosti povsem zanesljivi, medtem ko so moji kao osnovani na govoricah. ne, autozine je ugledna, izjemno dobra in 'bullshit free' stran, kjer delajo svoje raziskave in teste in ne prepisujejo z drugih strani!

p.s.
medosna 145/145: 2540 mm
medosna bravo/brava: 2540 mm

sicer pa lahko sam preveriš...
156ka ---> 2595 mm
GTV/Spider (2003) ---> 2540 mm
Lybra ---> 2593 mm
155ka ---> 2540 mm
147ka ---> 2546 mm
159 ---> 2700 mm
Brera ---> 2525 mm

zdj pa dejmo malo razložit... Če tudi recimo 156 je dokaj isti šmorn okoli varnosti le da ima daljšo havbo napram bravotu/155/145... Sicer se vse te mm številke ujemajo, ampak potemtakem bi bila 147ka na malce predelanem 145kinem podvozju delana ampak dvomim... torej tukaj imate servirane podatke, sedaj pa le naprej v konstruktivnosti debate 8)
Zadnjič spremenil Pepsi, dne Sr Jan 02, 2008 1:58 pm, skupaj popravljeno 1 krat.
It doesn't matter what you drive, but how you drive it :)
Uporabniški avatar
zdravc
Alfa Freak
Alfa Freak
Prispevkov: 603
Pridružen: Sr Sep 12, 2007 3:30 pm

zdravc napisal/-a:zakaj bi mislil da je enako dolga? ogrodje je enako, ampak vpetje vzmetenja je drugacno, tako je tudi medosna malo daljsa. temu drugace v anglescini pravijo floor pan, in je glavni/nosilni element strukture avtomobila.

osnova ima enak izvor, cetudi je zunanja oblika drugacna.
recimo fiat coupe in 145 imata to strukturo skoraj do pikice enako.

medosne sem napisal, da je jasno da sta bravo/brava in 145/146 na povsem enakem podvozju.
kar pa za 156 nisem pisal. beri zgoraj.


lahko pa še enkrat preberete tole, in tokrat bolj pozorno:
Tipo's derivatives
Fiat�s platform sharing strategy reached its peak during the Tipo era. Fiat Tipo was launched in 1988 as Fiat�s Golf-beater. Its simple front MacPherson struts / rear trailing arms platform was soon found sharing with a dozen models in the group. Here is the complete listing (loaded from my memory) - Fiat Tipo, Fiat Tempra, Lancia Dedra, Lancia Delta, Alfa 155, Alfa 145/146, Fiat Brava/Bravo/Marea, Fiat Coupe, Fiat Punto, Alfa GTV/Spider, Alfa 156 and Lancia Lybra.

The earliest derivatives did not changed much the hard points position, hence essential dimensions. These include today�s 145/146, Delta and Brava/Bravo/Marea. They differ from each other by packaging, styling and suspension tuning. Fiat and Lancia share the same engines and transmission. Alfa got modified 4-cylinder engines (e.g. with twin-spark added) and sportier suspension setup.

146 is a 145 with longer boot, although both of them are hatchback.

Brava is the 5-door version of the 3-door Bravo. Marea is the 3-box saloon version. Marea Weekend is an estate.

Alfa GTV / Spider, Alfa 156 and Lancia Lybra received much more development. GTV / Spider has multi-link replaces strut as rear suspension. The front still rides on strut. On the contrary, 156 has the front suspension changed to double-wishbones while using struts at the rear. Lybra remains strut in front but introduces a new GLA (Guided Lateral Arm) rear suspension. Again, Alfa has its own engines (including V6s) while Fiat and Lancia share the same engines. Alfa even got advanced transmission such as Selespeed. Although there are still a lot of common components sharing among them, it is no longer adequate to call these cars as sharing platform.
ce koga zanima in ne zna anglesko naj pove, pa bom povzel.


edit:
na pepsijev edit: za 147 nimam podatkov, sem si jo pa v živo natančno ogledal na dvigalu spodaj, in se ne razlikuje od 156ke.
Uporabniški avatar
TribesMan
Addicted to Alfa
Addicted to Alfa
Prispevkov: 9775
Pridružen: Če Jul 12, 2007 6:17 pm
Vozilo: Something else

Da dodam še nekaj k tej zmedi podatkov... quote iz wikipedie:
The 156 uses platform derived from 155, which platform was derived Fiat Group´s "Tipo" platform. It can be seen as new platform being so different than the original "Tipo" one.[15][16] The 156 was a highly developed front-wheel drive car (the Cross/Sportwagon Q4 offered four-wheel drive in left-hand drive markets) with a double high wishbone front suspension and all independent multi-link rear suspension,[1][17]which is made of telescopic vertical strut with coaxial spring and two transverse links with different lengths and a longitudinal strut, with this structure the rear wheels have a small passive steering ability.[8]
Še dodatek:
It's a common mistake to think that car have McPherson rear suspension, because shock absorber has combined with the spring, but this isn't McPherson.
Uporabniški avatar
zdravc
Alfa Freak
Alfa Freak
Prispevkov: 603
Pridružen: Sr Sep 12, 2007 3:30 pm

wow, se mi je zdelo čudno zakaj bi šli na mcphearsona, ki proti traling arm nima bistvene prednosti.
multilink, to se slisi veliko bolje.
Uporabniški avatar
TribesMan
Addicted to Alfa
Addicted to Alfa
Prispevkov: 9775
Pridružen: Če Jul 12, 2007 6:17 pm
Vozilo: Something else

Fiatov press release od 156 iz leza 1997:

klik
Rear
This layout is particularly advanced in both geometry and construction terms. It is based essentially on a telescopic vertical strut with a coaxial spring, two long transverse links and a longitudinal strut. The telescopic upright incorporates a pressurised dual-rate damper with a distinctly offset coil spring to minimise friction. The damper stop also comes into play in the final suspension travel phase and is made of 'Cellasto', a special closed-cell polyurethane that retains its smoothly flexible action over time. The two transverse links are pressed out of high tensile steel and are of different lengths in order to exploit the system's elastokinematic properties to produce a tiny steering effect. Toe-in is regulated by a cam system on the rear link that is lighter and simpler to repair than a traditional screw system. The two transverse arms and the anti-roll bar supports are anchored to a vacuum-cast light alloy sub-frame which weighs about 1.8 kg less than a conventional steel cross-member.
Uporabniški avatar
TribesMan
Addicted to Alfa
Addicted to Alfa
Prispevkov: 9775
Pridružen: Če Jul 12, 2007 6:17 pm
Vozilo: Something else

The Alfa 147 fears no comparison where safety is concerned. Starting with the excellent torsional and flexural rigidity of the bodyshell: 110,000 kgm/rad for the 3-door and 95,000 kgm/rad for the 5-door version
Ti podatki so navedeni malce drugače kot tisti na prvi strani... kgm/rad ni čist isto kot Nm/deg...

Po pretvorbi dobimo ven:

147 3-door: ~19.200
147 5-door: ~16.600
Uporabniški avatar
Alfaspider
Addicted to Alfa
Addicted to Alfa
Prispevkov: 2664
Pridružen: Po Okt 13, 2003 8:36 am
Član Alfa Kluba: 0

Ker se ravno z varnostjo 147ke ukvarjam
Žal samo 3 *, vrata se ob trku odprejo idt... Priporočam ogled filmčkov pred naslednjim norenjem.
http://www.euroncap.com/tests/alfa_rome ... 1/108.aspx
You need two Ferraris powersliding around the bentley, that is also powersliding
Uporabniški avatar
zdravc
Alfa Freak
Alfa Freak
Prispevkov: 603
Pridružen: Sr Sep 12, 2007 3:30 pm

torej ker sem resno neucakan in kar vre iz mene, naj povem da bo moja QVjka doživela spremembe v duhu te teme, in sicer danes zvem ce mi je uspelo dobiti eno zaleteno 156ko 2.0 T.S., ki bo sluzila kot donator motorja, zato ker je v tej 156 skoraj nov in še pomembneje ... *khm* ostalih delov. naj namignem da so povezani s to temo.
sicer pa tudi pripravjam ojačitve šasije, recimo strut bar je že skoraj končan, potem pride na vrsto še nekaj dodatnega švasanja obstoječe karoserije, ko bo karoserija gola, se bom še sproti odločil kaj bom naredil.

ontopic:
BMW E46 z steno med prtlažnikom in sedeži je precej bolj tog od E46 s sedeži, ki se podrejo. zgleda kar precejšen kompromis med praktičnostjo, udobjem in lego.
Uporabniški avatar
tha_man
Alfist
Alfist
Prispevkov: 346
Pridružen: Ne Sep 04, 2005 6:22 pm
Vozilo: Alfa 146 1.6 TS, Grande Punto 1.4 T-Jet, MX-5 2.0 RC

Hmm, malo sem poiskal po netu, in sem na par mestih naletel na skoraj iste številke za 156 kot jih je zgoraj navedel TribesMan za 147. Kaj je zdaj pravilno?
Odgovori
  • Informacija